#537 1919 Victory Issue

Basic Information 

Color:  Violet
Subject: Victory and Flags
Watermark: NONE
Printing method: Flat Plate
Perforations: 11
Scott #: 537
Issued:  March 3rd, 1919

 Value 

An unused stamp with perfect gum: $4-$7
An unused stamp with gum and a hinge mark: $1-$2
A used stamp: $1-$1.75

A case of too much thinking

A large die proof (537P1)
Click the image to enlarge

Originally designed to commemorate 100 years of peace between English-speaking nations in 1914, WWI canceled the idea. Only after WWI ended could the idea be brought back to the table. Philatelists and the press called for a stamp to celebrate the peace that greeted 1919, so it seemed natural to resurrect this peace stamp.

But the design had to be changed. First and foremost, to avoid offending our European allies, we decided not to put the US flag front and center, as it would give the impression that America had won the war. So the US flag was tucked behind an allegorical figure of Victory. Four allies' flags flanked Victory, with Britain and France in the prominent outer positions and the lesser allies, Belgium and Italy, filling the space between. Belgium came before Italy, as it entered the war first.

This design turned out to be overthought and overworked. It resulted in a crowded design, made worse by the fact that obtaining good-quality ink was impossible after the war ended, creating a less-than-ideal stamp. The stamp was critically panned and was not popular with the public. The Post Office instructed its postmasters not to use it as the default 3¢ stamp, and to sell it only if specifically requested.

Usage

A first day of issue cover, March 3rd, 1919

Up to July 1st 1919, a 3¢ stamp in the United States primarily paid the domestic first-class postage rate for letters, which had been raised from 2¢ to 3¢ in November 1917 to fund World War I.

The rate increase to 3¢ went into effect under the Revenue Act of 1917 to help finance America's involvement in WWI. This 3¢ first-class rate remained in effect through 1918 and 1919, before reverting to the standard 2¢ rate on July 1, 1919.

This was the only stamp specifically created for the first-class rate of 3¢.

#537a, #537b, #537c

#537a
Deep Red Violet

#537b
Light Reddish Violet

#537c
Red Violet

The Plates and a Pane

#537 was issued with the following plate #'s

Number only
9412-19, 9426-33

Click the image to enlarge

A full pane of 100, there are four panes to a sheet

Essays and Proofs

537-E1

Click image to enlarge

537-E1

Click image to enlarge

537-E2

Click image to enlarge

537-E3

Click image to enlarge

537-E4

Click image to enlarge

The Inspiration for the Design

Liberty 

The Bureau of Engraving and Printing artist Claire A. Huston designed #537, which features a classical standing figure of Liberty (or the Goddess of Victory) holding a sword and scales of justice, flanked by the flags of the Allied nations.