#499 1917 2¢ P11 Type I

Basic Information 

Color:  Carmine
Type: I
Subject: George Washington
Watermark: NONE
Printing method: Flat plate
Perforations: 11
Scott #: 499
Quantity issued: unknown 
Issued:  March 23rd, 1917

 Value for singles (#499)

An unused stamp with perfect gum: $1
An unused stamp with gum and a hinge mark:  25¢-50¢
A used stamp: 15¢

 Value for booklet Panes of 6 (#499e)

An unused pane of 6 with perfect gum: $1.50-$2.50
An unused pane of 6 with gum and a hinge mark: $1
A used pane of 6: -

 Value for booklet Panes of 30 (#499f)

An unused pane of 30 with perfect gum: $15,000
An unused pane of 30 with gum and a hinge mark: $3,000-$7,000
A used pane of 30: $4,500

Changing from 10 to 11 perforations

#499 with prominent recuts to the hair

The United States Post Office changed the perforation gauge on flat plate stamp sheets from Perforation 10 (P10) to Perforation 11 (P11) in early 1917 because P10 was too difficult to separate without damaging the stamp. 

This transition represented the final step in a decade-long trial-and-error process by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to find a balanced perforation standard:

Perforation 12 (Used until 1914): The Post Office originally used P12, but the holes were punched too closely together. Heavy-use businesses complained that the sheets were too flimsy and brittle, frequently falling apart and tearing prematurely at the slightest touch.
Perforation 10 (1914–1917): In an attempt to strengthen the sheets, the Bureau switched to a wider P10 gauge. However, this went too far in the opposite direction. The holes were spaced too far apart, making the paper too tough to tear. Postal clerks and citizens frequently ripped or ruined the stamps when trying to separate them from the sheet.

Perforation 11 (Introduced 1917): P11 was implemented as the ideal "Goldilocks" middle ground. It provided enough structural integrity so sheets wouldn't fall apart during shipping, while remaining clean and easy enough to tear apart by hand.

Stamps for the soldiers (#498f)

#499f booklet pane of 30

The #499f booklet pane of 30 was produced in August 1917 specifically to provide convenient postage for U.S. servicemen and associated civilians serving in France during World War I as part of the American Expeditionary Forces (A.E.F.). 

Reason and Background 

Postcard and Letter Writing: After the U.S. entered World War I, postal authorities expected troops deployed to Europe to send large numbers of letters and illustrated postcards back home to their families.
Convenient Format: The 1¢ green and 2¢ rose stamps were packaged into special pocket-sized booklets—each containing 10 panes of 30 stamps—so soldiers could easily carry them in wallets or field kits without the stamps sticking, tearing, or getting ruined in damp conditions.
Short-Term Use: The need for these booklets ended abruptly shortly after their arrival. On October 3, 1917, the U.S. Congress enacted free first-class franking privileges for active-duty military personnel, rendering the stamps in the A.E.F. booklets largely obsolete for active soldiers. As a result, only a small number were ever distributed before unsold quantities were eventually destroyed.

Spotting the Common Fakes

Differentiating a genuine American Expeditionary Forces (A.E.F.) booklet pane of 30 (Scott #499f) from clever fakes or sheet conversions requires close inspection. Because a genuine unused #499f pane has a high value, counterfeiters sometimes try to manufacture them by taking cheap sheets of 100 or imperforate sheets and trimming or adding perforations. A certificate of authenticity is usually required when selling #499f.

True identification relies on the physical traits resulting from how the Bureau of Engraving and Printing modified its machinery to manufacture these specific booklets. 

1. Paper Grain and Stamp Dimensions (The "Dry Shrinkage" Test). The most definitive scientific method to spot a fake relies on the physical dimensions of the stamps. 

The Process: To print these unique 30-stamp layouts (10 columns by 3 rows), the Bureau rotated the normal stamp paper 90 degrees on the flat plate press. 
The Result: Early U.S. flat-plate stamp production involved wetting the paper before printing. When the rotated paper dried, it shrank horizontally across the grain rather than vertically.
How to Check: Genuine A.E.F. stamps from a booklet pane are slightly wider and shorter than standard 1¢ sheet stamps (#499). If you lay a standard #499 sheet stamp or a vertical strip of an imperforate #482 directly over a suspected #499f pane, the lines and design heights won't align perfectly. If the stamps match standard sheet dimensions exactly, it is a fake.

2. Selvedge/Margin and Tab Placement: Genuine panes feature a distinct selvage tab designed to be bound into the booklet. 

Left or Right Only: The binding tabs for A.E.F. booklets were positioned on either the far left or far right side of the 30-stamp block.
Watch for Added Tabs: Forgers often take a regular block of sheet stamps and try to attach a fake margin strip to simulate a binding tab. Use high magnification to inspect the paper fibers along the margin tab seam to ensure it is continuous and has not been seamlessly glued or repaired.

#499a, #499b, #499c, #499e, #499g, #499h 

#499a
Vertical Pair
Imperf. Horizontal

#499b
Vertical Pair
Imperf. Vertical

#499c
Vertical Pair
Imperf. in-between

#499e
Booklet pane

#499g
Double impression

#499h
Lake color

Usage and a Pane

The earliest known use of #499e, June 19th 1917

In 1916, a 2¢ stamp was the standard rate for domestic first-class letters (weighing up to 1 ounce). It also covered the international postcard rate and could be combined to pay basic parcel post fees. 

Because of its high demand, the 2¢ stamp was the most heavily printed denomination. Its usage varied depending on the type of mail being sent:

First-Class Letters: The 2¢ rate paid for a sealed, handwritten or typewritten letter delivered anywhere within the United States or its territories.
Parcel Post: Beginning in 1913, the U.S. Post Office introduced a new parcel post system. Initially, packages required special Parcel Post stamps. However, confusion over the rules led the Postmaster General to authorize regular 2¢ and standard postage stamps for parcel use by June 1913. 
Postal Cards: A standard international postcard required a 2¢ stamp.

The first-class rate changed on November 17th, 1917, to 3¢.

A full pane of #499, there were four panes to a sheet of stamps

The Plates

#499 was issued with the following plate #'s

Number only
 
10190-93, 10198-99, 10200-01, 10204-08, 10210-17, 10226-29, 10234-41, 10266-73, 10286-89, 10304-05, 10313-14, 10319-24, 10333-34, 10339-42, 10353- 56, 10372-73, 10378-79, 10392-93, 10398-99 10412-13, 10418-19, 10424-29, 10434-35, 10442-43, 10456-57, 10462-65, 10481-84, 10493, 10495-99, 10500, 10505-08, 10515-24, 10531-38, 10545-56, 10559-64, 10569-70, 10577-79, 10581-82, 10585, 10589-90, 10593-94, 10597-98, 12938-69, 12974-91, 12993-99, 13000-01, 13006-09, 13014-17, 13194-97, 13202-09, 13227-30, 13235-38, 13241-48, 13260-63, 13296-99, 13433-42, 13451-58, 13475-90, 13493-96, 13518-21, 13524-27, 13532-35, 13540-43, 13548-51, 13560-67, 13587-94, 13659-74, 13679-91, 13698-99, 13700-17, 13724-39, 13746-61, 13768-75, 13780-83, 13792-95, 13848-51, 13864-71, 13878-89, 13898-99, 13900-05, 13912-15,13924-27, 13932-35, 13944-47, 13954-57, 13970-75, 13978-81, 13986-89, 13992-99, 14002-05, 14008-11, 14014-25, 5990, 7322, 7393, 7398, 7456, 7495, 7501, 7569, 7581, 7589-90, 7640-41, 7682, 7698-99, 7701, 7703, 7705, 7707-11, 7713-16, 7721-22, 7724, 7728, 7730, 7732, 7737, 7760, 7773, 7792, 7795, 7797, 7801-02, 7808-09, 7816-19, 7823, 7839-45, 7847-48, 7854-59, 7866-73, 7921-23, 7930-32, 7934-36, 7941-42, 7944-49, 7951-52, 7955, 7982-83, 7985-89, 7995-96, 8000-02, 8004-06, 8009-12, 8014, 8017-33, 8041, 8053, 8055, 8058-59, 8063-67, 8069-70, 8083-90, 8180-82, 8498-99, 8500-05, 8514-25, 8531-42, 8546-53, 8870-72, 8874-77, 8886-87, 8952-54, 9098, 9100-02, 9119-28, 9131-32, 9139-40, 9156-76, 9183-92, 9197-99, 9200-32, 9238-41, 9410-11, 9420-25, 9434-49, 9454-56, 9459-62

#499e was issued with the following plate #'s

Number only
 
10147-50, 10218-21, 10329-32, 10400-07, 10609-12, 10672-75, 10718-21, 10775-78, 10791-94, 11777-84, 12487-90, 12930-37, 13010-13, 13210-13, 13528-31, 13617-24, 13964-67, 7881-82, 7885, 7887, 7968-71, 8191, 8893-95, 9471-74

The Inspiration for the Design

George Washington bust by Jean-Antoine Houdon 

The vignette was based on a bust of George Washington by french sculptor Jean-Antoine Houdon.

Created in 1785 the bust is considered the most accurate likeness of the first U.S. president. Based on a life mask and clay model made at Mount Vernon, it captures Washington at age 53 with precise facial details, blending a Roman, toga-style aesthetic with realistic aging. It is considered one of the most accurate representations of Washington.