#564 1923 12¢ P11

Basic Information 

Color: Brown Violet
Subject:  Grover Cleveland
Printing method: Flat plate
Perforations: 11
Scott #: 564
Quantity issued:  447,511,777
Issued: March 20th, 1923

 Value

An unused stamp with perfect gum: $3-$5
An unused stamp with gum and a hinge mark: $2-$3
A used stamp: 25¢-50¢

#564a 

Vertical imperf between stamps
#564a

Usage 

#564 first day issue, dated March 20th, 1923
Only 1,000 first day covers were issued from Caldwell, New Jersey. Caldwell was one of three places the FDC was issued; the others were Boston and Washington, D.C. (the most common). Caldwell was the birthplace of Grover Cleveland

 The 12¢ stamp did not correspond to a standard, standalone single-weight domestic letter.  Like many higher-value denominations of the era, it was primarily used in combination with other stamp values.

Grover Cleveland's birthplace in Caldwell, New Jersey

Replacing the Washington-Franklins

The primary reason for introducing the Series of 1922–25 (historically known as the Fourth Bureau Issue) was to eliminate severe visual confusion that was costing the Post Office Department thousands of dollars in lost revenue annually.

The Problem: The Washington-Franklin Monotony
Since 1908, the United States had been using the Washington-Franklin Heads Series. In that older series, almost every stamp looked nearly identical:

  • Stamps from 1¢ to 7¢ all featured the exact same portrait of George Washington.
  • Stamps from 8¢ to $5 all featured the exact same portrait of Benjamin Franklin.

Because the frames and vignettes were identical across dozens of denominations, postal clerks processing mountains of mail had to rely almost entirely on reading the tiny denomination text or spotting subtle color variations on the fly. This lack of distinctive features caused major visual mix-ups, letting short-paid mail slip through undetected and resulting in major financial losses for the government.


The Solution: Visual Distinction

Prompted by requests from thousands of postal employees, the U.S. Post Office Department announced a radical overhaul to introduce unmistakable variety. The new 1922–25 series resolved the confusion by giving each denomination a completely unique identity:

Diverse Historical Figures: While Washington and Franklin remained on a few core values (like the workhorse 2¢ stamp), other denominations featured distinct portraits of American presidents and prominent figures (such as Theodore Roosevelt, Garfield, Hayes, and Woodrow Wilson).
National Landscapes and Icons: Higher denominations introduced highly recognizable national scenes and monuments, including Niagara Falls, the Statue of Liberty, the Golden Gate, and the Lincoln Memorial.
Orientation Shifts: To make high-value stamps immediately obvious, issues from 17¢ to $5 were printed horizontally (landscape), visually contrasting with the vertical format of cheaper everyday stamps.

The Public Backlash

When the Post Office first announced the change, the move drew mixed reviews. Several contemporary newspapers and critics openly accused the Post Office Department of updating the designs purely to satisfy and exploit stamp collectors for profit. The Post Office strictly denied these rumors, insisting the changes were a functional necessity driven by logistics and revenue protection.

This iconic series ultimately marked the end of an era, serving as the final definitive series printed entirely using the traditional flat plate press before the Post Office fully transitioned to high-speed rotary presses.

The plates and a full pane

#564 was issued with the following plate #'s

Numbers only
14404-07, 15350-52, 15692-95, 16257, 16404-06, 16515
17470-72, 8031-32, 18398, 18424, 18921-23, 19161-63

Number and five-pointed star
17418-20, 18398

Number and six-pointed star
17421

A pane of 100 of #564; there are four panes to a sheet of 400 

Proofs

564-P1

Click image to enlarge

The Inspiration for the Design

 Photograph of Grover Cleveland

The central portrait was engraved by John Eissler based on this historical photograph

 The 12-cent denomination commemorated Cleveland’s two non-consecutive terms as the 22nd and 24th U.S. President and recognized his reputation for political integrity, civil service reform, and fiscal conservatism.